1/23/2025

Protecting Your Shopify Business from Gift Card Scams

Gift cards are the quintessential GIFTING SOLUTION—easy to give, simple to use, and incredibly popular. However, this convenience comes with a hidden DANGER: the risk of gift card fraud. As a Shopify merchant, understanding how to protect your business from these SCAMS is critical. In this article, we're diving into the common fraudulent practices related to gift cards & how you can safeguard your online store from them.

Understanding Gift Card Fraud

Gift card fraud has been on the RISE, especially with the growing popularity of online shopping. Statistics from NoFraud indicate that over $510 million in gift cards are purchased every year. While these numbers reflect a booming gift card industry, they also indicate a fertile ground for fraudsters to operate. Here’s how scammers typically engage in gift card fraud:

1. Stolen Credit Card Information

Fraudsters use STOLEN credit card information to buy gift cards online. This method allows them to purchase gift cards under the cardholder's name—then quickly redeem these cards for products or services before the chargeback process can begin.

2. Account Takeover (ATO)

Scammers gain access to legitimate customers' accounts, often by stealing login credentials. They can then make unauthorized gift card purchases from these accounts. This fraud is particularly effective because it appears to be a regular purchase from a trusted source, making it easier to bypass security checks.

3. Bulk Purchasing and Reselling

Some scammers exploit merchant vulnerabilities by purchasing multiple gift cards using various online identities or stolen information. They then resell these gift cards, using online marketplaces where buyers are often unaware of the potential risks.

4. Bot Attacks

Fraudsters deploy automated BOT attacks to test various gift card codes and quickly find valid ones. These bots can input thousands of different combinations in a matter of seconds.

5. Return Fraud

One particularly insidious method involves purchasing products with gift cards and then returning them for cash or store credit. Here, merchants lose both the product and funds associated with that transaction.

Protecting Your Shopify Store

Implement Strong Security Measures

Securing your online store involves MULTIPLE layers of protection. Here are some effective strategies:

1. Monitor Transactions

Regularly review sales transactions to identify patterns that may indicate fraud. Watch for:
  • Multiple purchases using the same gift card within short spans of time.
  • Purchases made using different credit cards but linked to the same email or address.
  • High-value gift card purchases made in quick succession.

2. Strong Identity Verification

Since Shopify doesn't offer built-in ID verification at the moment, consider using third-party applications like Jumio or Onfido for identity verification. These tools help authenticate customers’ identities by comparing government-issued IDs with selfie images through facial recognition.

3. Limit Gift Card Capacity

Implement a policy to limit the number of gift cards customers can purchase within a certain timeframe. Restricting the total value or number of gift cards can reduce the chances of bulk fraudulent transactions.

4. Use Two-Factor Authentication

Enabling Two-Factor Authentication adds an additional security layer—requiring users to confirm their identity via a second device or method prior to making purchases. This makes it significantly harder for fraudsters to gain access to accounts.

5. Implement a Captcha System

Using a Captcha system at checkout can deter automated bot attacks. Require buyers to solve a simple puzzle or prove they're human before completing their purchase, which complicates how scammers operate.

Best Practices for Managing Gift Cards

6. Monitor Gift Card Balances

Keep an eye on how and when gift cards are redeemed. Flag any suspicious activity immediately. This includes analyzing the transaction history to spot abnormal patterns. Fraudsters often use stolen gift cards quickly, so being proactive can save you from losses.

7. Educate Your Customers

Create a COMMUNICATION PLAN that informs your customers about potential scams. Teach them how to identify red flags, such as:
  • Receiving unsolicited emails requesting gift card purchases.
  • Offers that seem too good to be true.
  • Requests for payment made exclusively through gift cards.

8. Establish Return Policies

Develop strict return policies surrounding gift card purchases. Ensure customers understand that returning any items purchased with gift cards will require additional verification to confirm legitimacy.

9. Analyze Customer Data

Utilizing analytics tools helps track customer behavior. Patterns in customer purchases often reveal much about potential fraud. Platforms such as Google Analytics can provide insights into shopping trends.

Tech Solutions for Fraud Prevention

10. Fraud Prevention Software

Investing in comprehensive fraud detection and prevention software can help you tackle potential risks associated with gift card transactions. Kount provides advanced fraud protection solutions and identity verification services. This way, you can prevent attacks before they happen and safeguard your revenue.

11. Use a Security App

There are numerous apps available on the Shopify App Store specifically designed for fraud detection and prevention. For instance, the Fraud Judge allows merchants to execute ID verification and chargeback protection, safeguarding against fraudulent purchases.

Leverage Conversational AI

To add an extra layer of consumer interaction & security, consider enhancing your online platform with a chatbot. Using Arsturn, you can create custom chatbots that address common inquiries about gift card purchases and help educate customers on safety measures. These chatbots can:
  • Answer frequently asked questions about gift card policies.
  • Alert customers of common scams to watch for.
  • Offer real-time assistance while handling transactions, enhancing customer engagement.

Handling Refunds and Chargebacks

When fraudulent activity occurs, it's essential to have a PLAN OF ACTION to manage the fallout:

12. Establish Chargeback Procedures

Enable procedures to manage chargebacks if they occur. Train your staff accordingly so there’s no delay. The more organized your response is, the better you can defend against false claims. Make it easy for customers to contact you with questions or concerns to mitigate any misunderstandings.

Conclusion

Protecting your Shopify business from gift card scams requires a comprehensive approach combining technology, monitoring, customer education, & strategic policies. By implementing robust security measures, investing in preventive software, and using technology like Arsturn for chatbots, you can greatly bolster your defenses. Stay aware, be proactive, and engage with customers in SMART & SECURE ways! Protect your business & keep those scammers at bay!
Start building smarter connections with your consumers today using Arsturn's intuitive chatbot technology, turning potential threats into opportunities for enhanced customer engagement.


Arsturn.com/
Claim your chatbot

Copyright © Arsturn 2025