1/26/2025

Can Shopify Import Etsy Reviews Without Infringement?

As the world of eCommerce continues to expand, many sellers find themselves juggling multiple platforms to reach a wider audience. One common scenario is when a seller, successful on Etsy, decides to migrate their operations to Shopify. An essential component of this migration is ensuring that all valuable customer reviews from the Etsy store are imported into the new Shopify platform. But the pressing question arises: Can Shopify import Etsy reviews without infringing on any legal guidelines?

Understanding the Legal Landscape

Before diving into the technicalities of importing reviews, let's take a look at the legal considerations surrounding this process. When it comes to customer reviews, both Etsy’s Buyer Policy and Seller Policy transparently outline guidelines that dictate how user-generated content like reviews can be handled.

Proprietary Content

The main concern stems from the nature of reviews: they represent customer feedback that belongs to the individual buyer. While sellers generally retain rights to the products they sell on Etsy, reviews are part of the buyer's experience and are often considered proprietary content. Hence, migrating these reviews to another platform, even for similar products, may raise infringement issues. Etsy emphasizes that customers should be able to control how their feedback is used and shared, which leads to a gray area when trying to transfer that data.

The Ins & Outs of Importing Reviews

Manual Importing via CSV File

One of the methods to import Etsy reviews into Shopify is by manually transferring them through a CSV file. Here’s how that process works:

Export Etsy Reviews: As a seller on Etsy, access your reviews and export them to a CSV file. This file will include essential data like reviewer names, product links, and star ratings.
Format the CSV: You must format the CSV file according to Shopify’s specifications. Shopify provides an example of their required CSV schema for review imports, which can usually be found on their documentation pages.
Import to Shopify: Once your CSV is correctly formatted, you can go to Settings > Apps Sales Channels > Product Reviews > Import to upload the CSV file.

Using Third-Party Apps

If the manual method sounds tedious (which it can be), utilizing third-party apps like Reputon or Shuttle may be beneficial. These apps often automate the import process and help retain the structure and integrity of your reviews. However, using these apps also involves a user agreement, meaning you must ensure they handle data in accordance with Etsy’s policies to avoid infringement issues.

Necessary Precautions to Avoid Legal Issues

Respecting User Rights

When importing reviews, always keep in mind that people’s opinions should be treated with respect. To abide by privacy regulations, ensure your reviews retain only the information necessary for displaying testimonials. Avoid using detailed personal information without consent, especially if a review includes identifiable data.

Another way to mitigate infringement risks is to reach out to your previous customers seeking their permission to transfer their reviews. Not only can this build goodwill with past customers, but it also complies with several data protection regulations that advocate for consumer consent.

Third-party Guidelines

If you plan to utilize third-party tools for review migration, familiarize yourself with their compliance with both Etsy's terms of service & Shopify's guidelines. Any misalignment can raise red flags and lead to infringement disputes.

The Risks of Non-compliance

Failing to adhere to Etsy’s policies when importing reviews can lead to various repercussions:

Account Suspension: Etsy may suspend or terminate your seller account if it is found that you have violated their terms. This is a risk no seller should take lightly.
Legal Consequences: Engaging in unauthorized use of customer content can lead to potential lawsuits or claims for damages, especially if a customer feels their rights have been infringed upon.
Brand Reputation: Being flagged for legal infringements can damage your reputation not just on Etsy but may affect how Shopify or other platforms view your business.

Alternatives to Review Migration

If importing reviews seems too fraught with complications, consider these alternatives:

Encourage New Reviews: Instead of moving old reviews, incentivize your Etsy customers to leave fresh reviews on your new Shopify store. This can be done through email campaigns offering discounts or exclusive content.
Leverage Social Proof: Focus on displaying user-generated content from different channels than reviews, like photos or shoutouts from customers. This shrinks concerns regarding legalities.

Final Thoughts: The Smart Way Forward

Importing reviews from Etsy to Shopify involves navigating a murky legal landscape. While it is technically feasible to transfer customer reviews, it's crucial to ensure compliance with Etsy’s terms of service and user rights maintenance. The best approach? Prioritize transparency and seek consent wherever possible.

At the same time, with a methodical approach, you can engage your customers successfully in Shopify without compromising on respect or legality. By creating avenues for new reviews while being mindful of previous content, your transition can be seamless.

Promoting Your Brand with Conversational AI

While you’re building your Shopify store and formulating customer engagement strategies, consider enhancing customer interactions with Arsturn. Arsturn offers a NO-CODE, customizable AI chatbot solution that seamlessly integrates with your Shopify store. Not only can you boost audience engagement, but you can also create chatbots that provide instant responses, insights for better service, and enhance your overall brand experience. Start with Arsturn's FREE TRIAL and begin transforming your customer interactions today!

Adopting best practices in compliance will safeguard your operations in the long run, while technologies like Arsturn will augment your ability to connect with customers effectively. Happy selling!